The Other Amora'im: The other Amora'im maintain that that Gezeirah Shavah is needed with regard to Meitav (See Daf 5a), in which case we cannot use it to detract from the literal interpretation of "Ayin Tachas Ayin".

The Other Amora'im (cont.): Only from a different source.

Clarification: Because Rebbi Eliezer holds that it is like Kofer, who pays the value of the Mazik, since the Torah refers to it as 'Kofer' ...

Source: ... (as we learned on the previous Amud) 'But you may take Kofer (for damaged limbs)'.

The Other Tana'im: Whereas the other Tana'im above (See Maharsha) hold that it is by Kofer exclusively that one pays the value of the Mazik, since it is a redemption of his soul.

Clarification: He (Rav Papa bar Shmuel) thought that it was a person who had wounded him, and that the Katan was old enough to feel the embarrassment.

Clarification: La'av Davka K'nas, only since there is no loss of pocket, he refers to it as 'K'nas.

Clarification: And Gezeilos and Chavalos require Mumchim, as the Gemara says in the first Perek of Sanhedrin (Daf 2b) ...

Reason: This may be because they are not common, whereas Hoda'os and Halva'os are.

Precedent: And so the Gemara says in 'ha'Megaresh' (Gitin, Daf 88b [See Tosfos DH 'I').

Question: There are many places (in Shas) where they judged the Dinim of Gezeilos?

Example #1: In ha'Gozel Kama (later, on Daf 96b) in the case of the man who stole a pair of oxen, and ...

Example #2: ... in ha'Gozel Basra, (on Daf 115a) in the case of the man from Narsha'ah who stole a Seifer', and in many other places ...

Answer 1: One can refute all those proofs however, by establishing the case where the owners seized the stolen articles ...

Answer #1 (cont.): ... or where they declared that they would fix a Din Torah in Eretz Yisrael, as the Gemara explains in the first Perek (Daf 15b).

Answer #2: Some commentaries explain that it is specifically Gezeilos that come about through Chavalos that are not so common ...

Example: ... such as where the quarrel that two people are having turns into a fight, until one of them grabs his friend's article and steals it. That is a case which is not common and where Beis-Din do therefore not 'carry out their Shelichus'.

Refutation: There are cases every day however, where we judge Dinei Gezeilos.

Reference: Tosfos already explained this at the end of the second Perek Daf 26b DH 'Hai').