What difference emerges if Beis Din said, "You must pay him," or they said, "Go pay him."
Would Beis Din later obligate him to swear that he paid.
If Aidim later came and testified that he did not pay, and he later says that he paid.
There is no difference, and in both cases he is believed to say that he paid, without a Shevu’ah.
Machlokes between Answers A and B.
Machlokes between Answers A, B, and C.
What is the Halachah when someone who is Chayav a Shevuah later says he swore, and then Aidim later said he didn’t swear, and then he later again says he swore?
He should swear now.
If Beis Din was actually Mechayeiv him, he is believed; if he was Mechayeiv himself he is not believed.
If Beis Din was actually Mechayeiv him, he is not believed; if he was Mechayeiv himself he is believed.
He is Mechayev a Shevuah that he can't swear, so he must pay.
Kenedgo Nishba V’Notel.
Do people repay a loan the same day as they borrow the money?
Some people do, but most people don’t.
Some people don’t, but most people do.
There is no majority one way or the other.
No one pays back the same day.
It depends on the amount of the loan.
When do we say that a person will not forge a Shtar, because he is scared of Beis Din?
If more than three people are written in the Shtar, a person is afraid to forge a false Shtar.
A person will not take the risk if he isn’t gaining anything.
If the due date is soon, he is afraid, if the due date is in the distant future he is not afraid.
People are always scared of forging loan documents, and are never scared of forging a sales document.
It depends on the Beis Din in town.
When Beis Din obligates a person to pay something in a Ma’aseh Beis Din, when is he believed to say that he already paid it?
Always.
Only with Aidim.
Either with Aidim or with a Shevu’ah.
Never, because Ma’aseh Beis Din is a considered like Aidim.
Never, because Ma’aseh Beis Din is a considered like Aidim.