When must a Shomer take note of the item that each person gave him, when taking objects from two people?
Always.
Never.
Only when the two objects are given to him together.
Only when the two objects are given to him separately.
Only when the two people pointedly say that they want him to remember.
What is done with the third Maneh, which the Shomer is unsure of whom it belongs to?
Divide it in half and give half to each of the two people.
Yehei Munach Ahd Sheyavo Eliyahu.
Kol De’alim Gavar.
Divide it in half and give half to each of the two people, if they swear a Shevua that it is their’s.
Do the Goral HaGra.
When must a Shomer or Ganav pay each of two people the entire amount, when he is unsure of which one he owes the money to?
Always.
Only when they threaten him.
When he is paying to be fulfill his Chiyuv Bidai Shamayim.
When each of them has a definite claim.
By a chicken which lays eggs, and makes more chickens, so both people will have the entire amount — the chicken — that they are claiming.
How does the Gazlan respond to the two people claiming the extra Maneh?
He is silent.
He says “I don’t know who you are.”
He tries to convince them that they don’t want it; too much Gashmiyus isn't good.
Machlokes between answers A and B.
Machlokes between answers B and C.
Why does the Mishna need to state the case of two Keilim, one worth 100 and one worth 1000?
We would think that we only set aside the third part when no Hefsed will come out of it.
We would think that when both people are claiming the Kaili that is worth so much more (1000), there is no point in giving one of them the far cheaper Keli (100).