More Discussions for this daf
1. The Wife Of The Chasid 2. Doresh El ha'Meisim 3. POINT BY POINT OUTLINES OF THE YERUSHALMI
4. Berachos 018b Doresh El ha'Meisim 5. Traveling with a Torah scroll 6. Halachos of Honoring the Dead.
7. Shmuel's Father and Dumah 8. How Did People Learn in the Time of the Gemara? 9. Ma'aseh of the Shtei Ruchos- Lashon Hara?
10. Hidden Zuz 11. Beis Kevaros 12. אלמא ידעי
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BERACHOS 18

Sam Kosofsky asked:

Rabbotai,

On daf 18/b we find stories of people communicating with the dead. Shmuel seeks out his father who was niftar, talks to him and gets information about where yesomim's money is and helps Levi get to the Mesivta D'Rekia. It was important information regarding tzedaka but why was there no issur of "doresh el hamisim," involved?

B'kavod and good moed,

Sam Kosofsky

The Kollel replies:

(a) The SEFER YERE'IM (#91, cited in Sefer Beis Yosef) answers that the prohibition of "Doresh El ha'Meisim" applies only when a person tries to communicate with the body of the dead person. It is permitted, though, to communicate with the soul of the dead person, because -- since a soul does not die -- this is not called being "Doresh El ha'*Meisim*."

(b) The MAHARSHA points out that Shmuel's communication with the dead occurred while he was asleep, in a dream (this must be so, points out the Mitzpeh Eisan, because Shmuel was a Kohen and prohibited from entering a cemetary). It could be that communicating with the dead in a dream is not an action of "Doresh El ha'Meisim."

Kol Tuv,

-Yisroel Shaw