When does R. Shimon ben Yehudah say that R. Shimon argues with the Tana Kamma?
In the first case only: Where the person went on the first Shvil and did not enter the Beis Hamikdash, and then went on the second Shvil and did enter the Beis Hamikdash.
In the second case, understood like this, only: He went on the first Shvil, entered the Beis Hamikdash, became Tahor, went on the second Shvil, and entered the Beis Hamikdash a second time.
In the second case, understood like this, only: He went on the first Shvil, entered the Beis Hamikdash, became Tahor, went on the second Shvil, and entered the Beis Hamikdash a second time, having forgotten that he had entered the first time.
In the first case and second understanding of the second case (Answers A and C). In the first case and any scenario of the second case (Answers A, B, and C).
In the first case and any scenario of the second case (Answers A, B, and C).
What is Asher Chatah Bah is telling us?
That a person must be aware of Bah – “It,” that is, the specific Aveirah that he did, to be obligated in a Chatas.
That Misaseik in Chalavim and Arayos is Chayav.
That a person must have been aware of the action he was doing when he did the Aveirah to be obligate in a Chatas, and not a Misaseik.
Machlokes between Answers A and B.
Machlokes between Answers A and C.
What is the Halachah of someone who was Mechavein to be Magbiah a Tolush vegetable, and inadvertently cuts a Mechubar vegetable?
He is Chayav a Chatas, because he did a Melachah on Shabbos.
He is Potur, because there is no Meleches Machashaves.
He is Potur, because it is a Misasek.
Abaye and Rava disagree; one says he is Potur because of Meleches Machashaves, and one says he is Potur because of Misaseik.
Abaye and Rava disagree; one says he is Chayav, and one says he is Potur because of Meleches Machashaves.
When does R' Shimon hold that an Asham Talui is brought?
When the person didn’t know if he at all did an Aveirah.
Both when the person didn’t know if he at all did an Aveirah, as well as when the person knows that he did an Aveirah but didn’t know which Aveirah he did.
Only by Chalavim and Arayos.
For everything but Chillul Shabbos, because Meleches Machshaves is necessary.
For everything but Chalavim and Arayos, for it is more Chamur.
How did Shmuel explain the case that R' Yehoshua and R' Eliezer are arguing?
Avad Milakeit Milibo.
Only by two Sheimos, and not by Sheim Achas.
Not by Bein Hashemashos.
Even by Shechoros and Leveinos.
By every case when someone forgot which Aveirah he did.