מודר הנאה Why can't he lend to him?
- They made נדרים against each other.
- We are afraid it may come to him borrowing.
- It makes the lender feel good so we forbid it.
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes B&C.
Reuven vowed "I will never plow my field with your cow." May someone else?
- Yes.
- No.
- Only if he usually plows.
- Only if he doesn't.
- Machlokes A&C.
One is מודר הנאה and is starving. The one he swore against may ______ .
- feed him
- have others feed him
- be מפקר food for him if no one is around
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes B&C.
הפקר leaves my posession ________ .
- immediately
- after it is acquired by another
- in 3 days
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes B&C.
ר' יוסי agees that if were מפקיר first the vow doesn't take effect. Why?
- He retracts.
- Talmid To'eh.
- Person doesn't have in mind that which he was מפקיר.
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes A&C.
Why does רבי יוסי argue?
- He holds it remains his.
- He holds גזירה משום מתנת בית חורון i.e. we are scared he didn't mean it.
- We are afraid people will take vows lightly.
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes A&C.