Question: Nesachim are entirely for the Mizbe'ach!

Answer: They are poured through the Shitim. (The Mizbe'ach does not consume them.)

Question: Minchas Nesachim is entirely consumed by the Mizbe'ach!

Answer: Some Menachos are (mostly) eaten by Kohanim. Presumably the one who vowed intended for something that is always Kalil.

(Mishnah): If one said 'Alai Zahav', he must bring at least a gold Dinar.

Question: Perhaps he meant Naska (an ingot; Tosfos - it is a fixed amount less than a Dinar)!

Answer (R. Elazar): He said 'coins'.

Question: Perhaps he meant Perutos!

Answer (Rav Papa): People do not make gold Perutos.

(Mishnah): If one said 'Alai Kesef', he must bring at least a Dinar.

Question: Perhaps he meant Naska!

Answer (R. Elazar): He said 'coins'.

Question: Perhaps he meant Perutos!

Answer (Rav Sheshes): The Mishnah discusses a place where silver Perutos are not used.

(Mishnah): If one said 'Alai Nechoshes', he must bring copper worth a silver Ma'ah.

(Beraisa - R. Eliezer ben Yakov): He must bring at least a small fork of copper.

Question: What use is there for this in the Mikdash?

Answer (Abaye): It is used to cut off burnt ends of wicks and to clean the ashes out of the lamps of the Menorah.

Version #1 (Beraisa - Others): If one said 'Alai Barzel', he must bring iron (at least) enough for Kalyah Orev (to prevent ravens from resting on the Heichal; Rashi - these are spikes, or an iron plate with a sharp edge pointing up; Aruch - it is a scarecrow.)

Question: How big must this be?

Answer (Rav Yosef): It must be one Amah by one Amah.

Version #2: If one said 'Alai Barzel', he must bring one Amah by one Amah.

Question: What use is there for this in the Mikdash?

Answer (Rav Yosef): It is enough for Kalyah Orev.

(Mishnah): If one said 'Alai Yayin', he must bring three Lugim of wine;

If he said 'Alai Shemen', he must bring one Log of oil;

Rebbi says, he must bring three Lugim.

If he knows that he vowed to bring a certain amount but does not remember how much, he brings the largest amount that the Tzibur ever brings in one day.

(Gemara - Beraisa): "Ezrach" is extra, to permit a Nedavah of wine. Three Lugim must be brought. (We never find less than this.)

Question: What is the source to allow bringing more?

Answer: "Yihyeh" permits this.

Suggestion: Perhaps one may bring less!

Rejection: "Kachah" (is Me'akev).

(Mishnah): If he said 'Alai Shemen', he must bring one Log of oil; Rebbi says, three Lugim.

Question: What do they argue about?

Answer (Rabanan): Chachamim hold Dun Minah u'Minah (when a matter is learned from another matter, we learn everything from the source):

We learn Nedavah of oil from Menachos. The smallest amount of oil in a Minchah is one Log;

Rebbi holds, Dun Minah v'Uki b'Asra (we only learn one law from the source, other laws are according to the law of the matter being learned);

We learn from Menachos that a Nedavah can be brought, but we learn the Shi'ur from Nesachim. The minimum we ever find is three Lugim (of wine).

Rejection (Rav Papa): Both of them hold Dun Minah u'Minah. If they learned from Menachos, Rebbi would agree that the Shi'ur is one Log.

Answer #2 (Rav Papa): Rebbi learns from "Ezrach" (i.e. Nesachim of wine). Three Lugim must be brought.

Rejection (Rav Huna brei d'Rav Noson): That is wrong!

(Beraisa): "Korban" teaches that Nedavah of wine may be brought. The Shi'ur is three Lugim.

Rav Huna: This is like Rebbi, who holds that the Shi'ur is three Lugim. This shows that he learns from "Korban"!

Admission (Rav Papa): Indeed, the Beraisa refutes me.

(Mishnah): If he knows that he vowed to bring a certain amount but does not remember how much, he brings the largest amount that the Tzibur ever brings in one day.

(Beraisa): He brings like the first day of Sukkos that falls on Shabbos.

(Mishnah): If one said 'Alai Olah', he must bring a lamb (or better);

R. Elazar ben Azaryah says, he brings a Tor or Ben Yonah (or better).

If he vowed to bring Bakar (cattle, for an Olah) but does not remember which, he brings a bull and calf;

If he vowed to bring a Behemah but does not remember which, he brings a bull and calf, ram and (adult) goat, kid (yearling goat) and lamb.

If he does not remember whether he specified an animal or bird, he brings all of these and a Tor or Ben Yonah.

If he vowed to bring Todah or Shelamim, he must bring a lamb (or a bigger animal);

If he vowed to bring a specific kind of Bakar but does not remember which, he brings a male calf and a female calf, and a bull and cow;

If he vowed a specific animal but does not remember which, he brings a male and female of each of the following - cow and calf, (adult) sheep and goat, kid and lamb.

If he vowed to bring a bull, he must spend (at least) a Maneh (25 Sela'im) for it and its Nesachim;

If he vowed to bring a calf, ram or lamb, he must spend (respectively) at least five, two or one Sela('im) for it and its Nesachim;

If he vowed to bring a bull (or calf, ram or lamb) for 25 (or five or two or one) Sela('im), he must spend this amount for the animal alone, without its Nesachim;

If he vowed to bring a bull for a Maneh and he brought two bulls for a Maneh, he was not Yotzei;

Even if each is worth almost a Maneh, he was not Yotzei.

If he vowed to bring a black animal and brought a white one (or vice-versa), or to bring a large animal and brought a small one, he was not Yotzei;

If he vowed to bring a small animal and brought a large one, he was Yotzei;

Rebbi says, he was not Yotzei.

(Gemara): The first Tana and R. Elazar ben Azaryah do not argue. R. Elazar gives the law in his locale (Rambam - there, people call Olas ha'Of (simply) Olah; Rashi - there, birds cost more than lambs), and the first Tana teaches for his locale. (Olah refers only to Behemos, or lambs cost more than birds.)

(Beraisa): If one vowed to bring an Olah for a Sela to the Mizbe'ach, he should bring a lamb, for no other animal can be offered for a Sela.

If he specified what he will bring for a Sela, but he does not remember what, he brings everything that can be offered for a Sela (also Soles, Levonah...)

(Mishnah): If he vowed to bring a specific kind of Bakar but does not remember which, he brings a bull and a male calf.

Question: It should suffice to bring a bull, even if he vowed to bring a calf!

Answer: Our Mishnah is Rebbi, who says that if he vowed to bring a small animal and brought a large one, he was not Yotzei.

Question (Mishnah): If he vowed to bring a bull for a Maneh and he brought two bulls for a Maneh, he was not Yotzei;

Even if each is worth almost a Maneh, he was not Yotzei.

If he vowed to bring a black animal and brought a white one (or vice-versa), to bring a large animal and brought a small one, he was not Yotzei;

If he vowed to bring a small animal and brought a large one, he was Yotzei;

Rebbi says, he was not Yotzei.

Summation of question: Will you say that the Reisha and Seifa are like Rebbi, and the middle is Rabanan?!

Answer: Indeed, the Reisha and Seifa are Rebbi, and the middle is Rabanan.

The Mishnah teaches that (not all agree to the Reisha); Rebbi and Chachamim argue about this.

(Mishnah): There were six boxes for Nedavah (money to buy Kitz ha'Mizbe'ach, Olos Nedavah of the Tzibur for when the Mizbe'ach is idle).

(Mishnah) Question: Why were there six?

Answer #1 (Chizkiyah): They correspond to the six Batei Avos (Rashi - subdivisions of each Mishmar of Kohanim), so there will be Shalom between them. (The money is divided equally, so each Beis Av will offer the same amount; R. Gershom - each Beis Av offers whatever is given on its day.)

Answer #2 (R. Yochanan): Because many coins were given for Nedavah, there were six boxes, lest the coins rot.

Answer #3 (Ze'iri): There was one box for each kind of animal (that one may vow to bring for an Olah, i.e. males) - bull, calf, ram, lamb, goat and kid;

This is like Rebbi, who says that if one brought a large animal in place of a small one, he was not Yotzei.

Answer #4 (Bar Pada): The boxes were for (redemption money of Korbanos sent to graze, e.g. if a replacement was offered in place of a lost Korban, e.g.) bulls and goats (of Chatas Tzibur), rams and lambs (of Ashamos), Mosaros (if one was Makdish money for a Korban and did not need all of it, the extra is Mosar) and Kalbonos (small additions to the half-Shekel that everyone must give to Hekdesh each year).