If the sister [of a Kohen Gadol] was a Mukas Etz [and she died] - R. Meir and R. Shimon say, he does not become Tamei for her. Chachamim say, he becomes Tamei for her.

Question: R. Meir and R. Shimon said properly according to these Tana'im [who switch the text. R. Shimon permits him to marry a Mukas Etz, for she is considered a Besulah, and similarly he may become Tamei for a Mukas Etz [sister]. However, Rabanan contradict themselves!

There (in the Parshah of rape, it says Na'arah Besulah), they say "Na'arah", and not a Bogeres; "Besulah", and not a Mukas Etz. And here, they say so (he may become Tamei for a Mukas Etz sister, even though it says "Besulah")!

Answer (R. Heila): Each place is expounded according to the verse there;

There (to become Tamei, it says) "ul'Achoso ha'Besulah", to exclude one who was raped or enticed;

Suggestion: Perhaps I exclude a Mukas Etz!

Rejection: "Asher Lo Haysah l'Ish" - one whose [loss of Besulim] was through a man, and not through something else.

"Ha'Kerovah" includes an Arusah (he is Mitamei for her). "Elav" includes a Bogeres.

Question: Rabanan contradict themselves! There (a husband inheriting his wife), they say "ha'Kerovah", and not an Arusah. "Elav" and not a divorcee. And here, they say so ("ha'Kerovah" includes an Arusah)!

Answer (R. Heila): Each place is expounded according to the verse there;

His sister is always inside (considered his kin, for whom he is Mitamei) until she [totally] leaves [her father's Reshus, through Nisu'in. Therefore, "ha'Kerovah" includes an Arusah]. His Arusah is always outside until she enters inside (Nisu'in. Therefore, "ha'Kerovah" excludes an Arusah for inheritance.)

A girl that [a Kohen Gadol] raped or enticed, he may not marry her. If he married her, we do not take her from him (make him divorce her). A girl that someone else raped or enticed, he may not marry her. If he married her, we take her from him.

He may not marry a minor, but he may marry one who did Mi'un.

Question: One who did Mi'un, is she not a minor?!

Answer: We wait for her to mature (become a Na'arah, and then he may marry her).