1)
(a)We learned in a Beraisa that the boiled wine and Aluntis (a beverage containing wine) of a Nochri is forbidden, but that 'Aluntis ki'Beri'asah' is permitted. What does 'Aluntis ki'Beri'asah' mean?
(b)Why is it permitted?
(c)Another Beraisa forbids making Aluntis on Shabbos, but permits Anumlin, which comprises wine, honey and peppers. What is Aluntis made of?
(d)What is the basic difference between them?
(e)Why is Aluntis forbidden on Shabbos, whereas Anumlin is permitted?
1)
(a)We learned in a Beraisa that the boiled wine and Aluntis (a beverage containing wine) of a Nochri is forbidden, but that 'Aluntis ki'Beri'asah' - Aluntis which the Nochri purchased from a Yisrael ...
(b)... which is permitted - because it was never wine whilst in the possession of a Nochri.
(c)Another Beraisa forbids making Aluntis on Shabbos, but permits Anumlin, which consists of wine, honey and peppers. Aluntis is made of - old wine, clear water and Afarsemon (balsam) oil.
(d)The basic difference between them is - that whereas Anumlin is made to drink, Aluntis is made to help cool down after a hot bath ...
(e)... and which therefore falls under the category of a cure, which the Chachamim forbade on Shabbos).
2)
(a)Why is wine that has been left uncovered, forbidden to drink?
(b)What do Rabah and Rav Yosef say about ...
1. ... diluted wine?
2. ... boiled wine?
(c)In answer to our She'eilah whether boiled wine is also permitted if left uncovered, we cite a statement of Rebbi Ya'akov bar Idi. What did he say?
(d)When the Rabbanan, who were visiting the sick Rebbi Yanai bar Yishmael together with Rebbi Yishmael ben Zirud, asked the same She'eilah, what did the latter cite Resh Lakish quoting Rebbi Chiya as having ruled?
2)
(a)Wine that has been left uncovered is forbidden to drink - because we are afraid that a snake drank from it, leaving its venom inside the remains.
(b)Rabah and Rav Yosef preclude ...
1. ... diluted wine - from the above fear.
2. ... boiled wine - from the Din of Yayin Nesech.
(c)In answer to our She'eilah whether boiled wine is also permitted if left uncovered, we cite a statement of Ya'akov bar Idi - who specifically precluded it from the prohibition.
(d)When the Rabbanan, who were visiting the sick Rebbi Yanai bar Yishmael together with Rebbi Yishmael ben Zirud, asked the same She'eilah, the latter cited Resh Lakish quoting Rebbi Chiya - who permitted it, too.
3)
(a)What did Rebbi Yanai bar Yishmael reply, when the Rabbanan (surprised at Rebbi Chiya's ruling) asked whether they could rely on it?
(b)Shmuel and Avalat the Nochri were once sitting together when someone brought them boiled wine to drink. What did Shmuel say to Avalat, who made a point of not touching the wine?
3)
(a)When the Rabbanan (surprised at Rebbi Chiya's ruling) asked whether they could rely on it, Rebbi Yanai bar Yishmael replied that - he personally, could vouch for its authenticity.
(b)Shmuel and Avalat the Nochri were once sitting together when someone brought them boiled wine to drink. When Avalat made a point of not touching the wine - Shmuel told him that this was not necessary, since the Chachamim permitted boiled wine that was touched by a Nochri.
4)
(a)What did Rebbi Chiya reply when his maidservant asked him whether some boiled wine that she had left uncovered was permitted or not?
(b)What did Rav Papa rule when the Shamash of Rav Ada bar Ahavah left some diluted wine uncovered? How did he qualify the ruling permitting it?
(c)When Rabah bar Rav Huna spied a snake swimming towards the boat in which he was transporting wine, he instructed his servant to 'blind the eyes' of the snake. What did the servant subsequently do?
(d)How did Rav Papa reconcile his previous ruling with this episode?
4)
(a)When Rebbi Chiya's maidservant asked him whether some wine that she had left uncovered was permitted, he replied - that it was.
(b)When the Shamash of Rav Ada bar Ahavah left some diluted wine uncovered, Rav Papa - forbade it since it was only slightly diluted (and the Chachamim only permitted if it was diluted properly [three parts water to one part wine]).
(c)When Rabah bar Rav Huna spied a snake swimming towards the boat in which he was transporting wine, he instructed his servant to 'blind the eyes' of the snake. The servant complied - by adding a bit of water to the wine.
(d)Rav Papa reconciled his previous ruling with this episode - by pointing out that, although a snake will drink wine that is slightly diluted, it will not take the risk of doing so when there are people who are actually watching (though it will if the wine is not diluted at all).
5)
(a)Rebbi Yanai (or bar Hedya) was once sitting in the house of Achburi drinking diluted wine, when a snake was seen approaching the half-empty barrel. What precautions had they taken against a snake drinking from the barrel?
(b)What did the clever snake do?
(c)Considering that the wine was diluted, how will we reconcile our earlier ruling precluding diluted wine from Yayin Megulin, with this episode?
(d)Why did Rav Ashi (or Rav Mesharshaya) object to this answer?
5)
(a)Rebbi Yanai (or bar Hedya) was once sitting in the house of Achburi drinking diluted wine, when a snake was seen approaching the half-empty barrel - which they had covered with a cloth as a precaution against a snake drinking from the barrel.
(b)The snake however - proceeded to fill the barrel with water until it reached the top and then to drink it from the saturated cloth.
(c)In spite of the fact that the wine was diluted, we reconcile our earlier ruling precluding diluted wine from Yayin Megulin with this episode - by differentiating between wine that was diluted by a person and wine that the snake itself diluted.
(d)Rav Ashi (or Rav Mesharshaya) objected to this answer - because that when it comes to Sakanah (as opposed to Halachah), it is better to be strict than to look for answers (in which case we ought to include diluted wine in the category of Yayin Megulin).
6)
(a)So what ruling does Rava finally issue regarding Yayin Megulin? What distinction does he draw between boiled wine and diluted wine?
(b)What is the Din regarding Yayin Nesech in these two regards?
6)
(a)So Rava finally concludes - that boiled wine is precluded from Yayin Megulin, but diluted wine is not ...
(b)... and the same applies to Yayin Nesech.
7)
(a)What did Rebbi Chilkiyah bar Tuvi rule when his Shamash fell asleep beside an open barrel of water? What distinction did he draw between night and day?
(b)What is the Halachah in this regard?
(c)What is the reasoning of ...
1. ...Rav, who would not drink water that came from Nochrim, though he would drink water that came from an Almanah?
2. ... Shmuel, who would do the reverse?
(d)In the second Lashon, Rav did just like he did in the first. What did Shmuel do?
7)
(a)When Rebbi Chilkiyah bar Tuvi's Shamash fell asleep beside an open barrel of water - he ruled that snakes are afraid of people even when they are asleep - in the day, but not at night.
(b)However, the Halachah in this regard is that - snakes are afraid of people who are awake, but not of those who are asleep (even in the day).
(c)The reasoning of ...
1. ...Rav, who would not drink water that came from Nochrim, but who would drink water that came from an Almanah is that - Nochrim are not conversant with the concept of Mayim Megulin, whereas a widow will do what she saw her husband do whilst he was alive.
2. ... Shmuel, who would do the reverse is that - whereas, on the one hand, neither is conversant with the concept of Giluy, Nochrim are more particular about cleanliness (in which case they will not leave water uncovered [to prevent anything dirty from falling into it).
(d)In the second Lashon, Rav did just like he did in the first - whereas Shmuel would drink water neither from a widow nor from a Nochri.
8)
(a)Rebbi Yehoshua ben Levi lists three wines that are not subject to Giluy. Two of them are Chad and Mar. What exactly, is ...
1. ... 'Chad'?
2. ... 'Mar'?
(b)What affect does Chad have on the flask in which it is placed?'
(c)The third is Masok, which is also know as 'Chulya'. What is 'Masok'? What causes it to turn so sweet?
(d)Rav Chama defines all three favorably. He interprets 'Mar' as tasting like (venomous) wormwood, and Masuk as a pleasant tasting wine. How does he define 'Chad'?
8)
(a)Rebbi Yehoshua ben Levi lists three wines that are not subject to Giluy. Two of them are ...
1. ... 'Chad' - which is a wine with a sharp taste, due to peppers and spices that have been added to it, and ...
2. ... 'Mar' - a bitter tasting wine.
(b)'Chad' - causes the flask in which it is placed to crack.
(c)The third wine is Masok - an exceptionally sweet-tasting wine, also know as 'Chulya', which turned so sweet from the effect of the sun.
(d)Rav Chama defines all three favorably. According to him, 'Mar' tastes like (venomous) wormwood, 'Masuk' like a pleasant tasting wine - whereas 'Chad' has a sharp taste due to the peppers and spices that are added to it (like Rebbi Yehoshua ban Levi).
9)
(a)What does Resh Lakish say about a sweet wine called 'Karina'?
(b)Rava explains that in its own country it is. Why is that?
9)
(a)According to Resh Lakish, a sweet wine called 'Karina' - is not subject to Giluy either.
(b)Rava explains that in its own country it is - because the snakes have gotten used to it.
30b----------------------------------------30b
10)
(a)According to Rava, for how many days after wine has turned sour is it still subject to both Giluy and Yayin Nesech?
(b)What do the Neherda'i say? In which case do they argue with Rava?
(c)For how long is wine fresh from the vat not subject to Giluy?
(d)Basically, cress is not subject to Giluy either. What does the Beraisa say about the b'nei Golah?
(e)In which case will even the b'nei Golah concede that cress is not subject to Giluy?
10)
(a)According to Rava, wine that has turned sour is still subject to both Giluy and Yayin Nesech - for another three days.
(b)The Neherda'i argue with Rava with regard to Giluy. According to them - a snake will continue to drink from it for longer than that.
(c)Wine fresh from the vat is not subject to Giluy - for the first three days.
(d)Basically, cress is not subject to Giluy either. But the Beraisa cites the b'nei Golah - who forbade it.
(e)Even the b'nei Golah will concede however, that cress is not subject to Giluy - if it contains vinegar (with which the snakes palate does not agree).
11)
(a)Likewise, Kutach ha'Bavli (a mixture of moldy bread, whey and salt) is not subject to Giluy, though the b'nei Golah are strict there too. What does Rav Menashi say about this? In which case will the b'nei Eretz Yisrael concede that it is subject to Giluy?
(b)Rav Chiya bar Ashi Amar Shmuel precludes 'Mei Tif-Tif' from Giluy. How does Rav Ashi explain 'Mei Tif-Tif'?
(c)Rav Chiya bar Ashi Amar Shmuel precludes the 'mouth of a fig' from Giluy. What is the 'mouth of a fig'?
(d)We establish this like Rebbi Eliezer. What does Rebbi Eliezer rule in a Beraisa about eating grapes and figs at night-time?
11)
(a)Likewise, Kutach ha'Bavli (a mixture of moldy bread, whey and salt) is not subject to Giluy, though the b'nei Golah are strict there too. Rav Menashi states that - if the mark of a snake's fangs are visible on it, then even the b'nei Eretz Yisrael will concede that it is forbidden.
(b)Rav Chiya bar Ashi Amar Shmuel precludes from Giluy 'Mei Tif-Tif', which Rav Ashi explains as - drops that follow each other in quick succession (a noise which frightens the snakes away).
(c)Rav Chiya bar Ashi Amar Shmuel precludes from Giluy the 'mouth of a fig' - the hole in the tip of the stalk where it was originally attached to the tree.
(d)We establish this like Rebbi Eliezer, who, in a Beraisa, permits eating grapes and figs at night-time, because the Pasuk in Tehilim writes "Shomer Pesayim Hash-m" (meaning that Hash-m guards the fools [provided they behave conventionally] see Seifer 'Seider Ya'akov').
12)
(a)Rav Safra in the name of Rebbi Yehoshua from Rome, lists three kinds of snake venom. What is the difference between the venom of a young snake, a middle-age snake and an old snake?
(b)We query this however, from a Beraisa. What does the Beraisa say about a fish, a snake and a Chazir? What do they all have in common?
(c)How do we reconcile this with Rav Safra, according to whom it seems, the older a snake gets, the weaker it becomes (like other species)?
(d)The ramifications of Rav Safra's statement are presented in a Beraisa. What does the Beraisa say about the tenth person drinking what remains in a jar or eating from a watermelon, after nine people have already partaken from it?
(e)What actually happened on one occasion?
12)
(a)Rav Safra in the name of Rebbi Yehoshua from Rome, lists three kinds of venom. The venom of a young snake, he says - shoots to the bottom of whatever it drinks, that of a middle-age snake - penetrates to the middle, whereas that of an old snake - floats at the top.
(b)We query this however, from a Beraisa. Which lists a fish, a snake and a Chazir - as the three species that gain strength as they get older.
(c)We reconcile this with Rav Safra, according to whom it seems, the older a snake gets, the weaker it becomes (like other species) - by confining his statement to the snake's venom, whereas the Beraisa is speaking about the general strength of the three animals concerned.
(d)The ramifications of Rav Safra's statement are presented in a Beraisa - which warns the tenth person not to drink from a jar or eat from a watermelon, after nine people have already partaken from it (in case a young snake drank from it).
(e)It once happened that - ten people drank and did not die, and when the tenth one drank, he died.
13)
(a)On what grounds should ...
1. ... the first person not have drunk from the jar or eaten from the watermelon?
2. ... the middle ones not have drunk or eaten either?
(b)What does the Beraisa say about 'Mayim she'Nisgalu'? What should one not do with it, besides pour it into the street, sprinkle it around the house, or use it for mixing cement?
(c)Why may one not pour it in the street?
13)
(a)Neither however, should ...
1. ... the first person have drunk from the jar or eaten from the watermelon - in case an old snake partook of it.
2. ... the middle ones have drunk or eaten either - in case a middle-age snake did so before him.
(b)Besides pouring Mayim she'Nisgalu into the street, sprinkling it around the house or using it for mixing cement - the Beraisa also forbids feeding an animal with it or washing one's face, hands and feet.
(c)One may not pour it in the street - in case someone walks past bare-footed, and the venom lodges between his toes and punctures an opening in his skin.
14)
(a)Acherim (Rebbi Meir) restricts the prohibition of washing oneself with Mayim Megulin to parts of the body which has cracks and splits. What problem do we have this?
(b)How do we then establish their Machlokes? Which three parts of the body (which the Tana Kama forbids) does Acherim permit?
(c)How do we reconcile the current Beraisa, which forbids feeding even one's own animal Mayim Megulin, with another Beraisa, which permits it?
(d)If a cat is immune to snake venom, why does the second Tana then forbid giving Mayim Megulin to somebody else's cat any more than to one's own?
14)
(a)Acherim (Rebbi Meir) restricts the prohibition of washing oneself with Mayim Megulin to parts of the body which has cracks and splits. The problem with this is that - it seems to concur with the Tana Kama, who forbids washing hands, face and feet (all of which have cracks in the skin) with Mayim Megulin,
(b)To establish their Machlokes - we confine Acherim to the front of the hands and the feet, and most of the face, precluding the back of the hands, the back of the feet and the cheekbones, which are smooth, and which he therefore permits, whereas the Tana Kama forbids them).
(c)We reconcile the current Beraisa, which forbids feeding even one's own animal 'Mayim Megulin' with another Beraisa, which permits it - by establishing the latter Beraisa with regard to a cat, which is immune to snake venom.
(d)The second Tana nevertheless forbids giving Mayim Megulin to somebody else's cat more than to one's own - because, even though the venom will not kill the cat, it will weaken it momentarily, causing the owner a loss, should he then attempt to sell it.