1)

TOSFOS DH ELA MELAMED SHE'HECHZIRAN YIRMIYAH V'YOSHIYAH MALACH ALEIHEM

úåñ' ã"ä àìà îìîã ùäçæéøï éøîéä åéàùéä îìê òìéäí

(Summary: Tosfos reconciles this with his explanation on Daf 12b and elaborates.)

åúéîä, ùäøé àçøé ùäçæéøï éøîéä ìà òîãå áàøõ ÷åãí çåøáï ë"à ì"å ùðä, ëãôøéùéú ìòéì áô"á (ãó éá:)...

(a)

Question: After Yirmiyah brought them back, they only remained in the land for another thirty-six years, as Tosfos explained earlier in the second Perek (on Daf 12b)

åà"ë ìà äâéòå òã äéåáì, åäéàê ðåëì ìîöåà "åéùîòå åéùìçå" ?

1.

Question (cont.): In that case, they did not remain there until the Yovel; so how can we find that "They listened and sent them away"?

åé"ì, ãðåëì ìîöåà àåúí òáãéí ùäéå ìäí ÷åãí ùâìå.

(b)

Answer: It is possible with regard to Avadim that they had before they went into Galus (See Avodah Berurah).

åäà ãôøéê ìòéì 'åäëúéá "åéùîòå åéùìçå" ...

(c)

Implied Question: And when the Gemara asked earlier 'Is it not written "And they heard and they sent away?"

òé÷ø äôéøëà îãëúéá (éøîéä ìã) "åéùîòå ëì äùøéí åëì äòí àùø áàå ááøéú" -îùîò ùðëðñå ááøéú ìùìç òáãéäí çôùéí áéåáì ëùéâéò äéåáì.

(d)

Answer: The real question is from the Pasuk (Yirmiyah, 34) "And all the princes and all the people heard that they entered into the covenant" - implying that they entered into a covenant to send away their Avadim when the Yovel arrived.

OTHER D.A.F. RESOURCES
ON THIS DAF