What is "Lo Sa'asun ke'Chol asher Anachnu Osim Poh ha'Yom - Ish Kol ha'Yashar be'Einav " referring to? What is the Pasuk coming to teach us?
Rashi: With reference to 11:31, "Ki Atem Ovrim es ha'Yarden", when it will become permitted to sacrifice Korbanos on Bamos, 1 the Torah is confining the Korbanos that one brings on them to Nedarim and Nedavos 2 - as hinted in the words "Ish Kol ha'Yashar be'Einav" 3 (until they build the Mishkan in Shiloh).
Ramban: In the desert, Yisrael were obligated to bring any animal that they wanted to eat to the Mishkan to be Shechted as a Korban. 4 On the other hand, there was no obligation to bring (private) Korbanos - even on Yom-Tov. 5 It therefore transpires that during those forty years, there was no such thing as a (private) Korban Chovah. 6 And the Pasuk goes on to explain how all that changed when they built Mishkan Shiloh and subsequently, the Beis-Hamikdash. 7
Rashbam: It supports what the Torah wrote in Pasuk 5, confining Korbanos to one fixed location, 8 as opposed to the situation in the desert, where the Mishkan moved from place to place, and they brought Korbanos wherever the Mishkan happened to be at the time. 9
Oznayim la'Torah: In the time of Moshe, "Ish Kol ha'Yashar be'Einav" referred to bringing voluntary offerings. Nowadays, it refers to stealing and robbing, adultery and murder. How times have changed!
Rashi: During the fourteen years that they conquered Eretz Cana'an and distributed it.
Rashi: But not Chata'os and Ashamos which are obligatory. Zevachim, 117b: With reference to Korb?nos Yachid. Korb?nos Chovah of the Tzibur howeveeeeee, they did bring (as implied by the word ?Ish ? ? - Torah Temimah).
Rashi: Implying Korbanos that one brings voluntarily. See also Torah Temimah, note 32.
Ramban: However, after the blood was sprinkled, they could be eaten anywhere, even outside the camp.
Ramban: Including Bechoros, Ma'aser Beheimah and Ma'aser Sheni.
Ramban: And that is what the Torah means when it adds "Ish Kol ha'Yashar be'Einav." See R. Chavel's notes, where he discusses various problems concerning the Ramban's explanation.
See Oznayim la'Torah on Pasuk 4 DH 'u'Vasa Shamah' #1.
See also Ba'al ha'Turim.
?ke?Chol asher Anachnu Osim Poh Hayom?. What are the connotations of the word ?Hayom??
